Pothole + Varrstoen BBS Replica = Massive Fail

[kenchan]

Originally Posted by Waizzz

+1 on the wheel part, but -1 on the Z33's are not worth dirt part.

oh ok, i didn't see that part!

[indyn]

maybe a Z with forged wheels should try the same pothole and see what happens.

[TypeOne]

Ugh... that's just nasty.

[Liquid_G]

that's what you get for faking the funk..

[chuckd05]

wow. this speaks volumes about why you should purchase quality items...

[FL 4Motion]

Originally Posted by pty370z

He deserves it for putting BBS center caps on replica wheels..

On a more serious note, I'm glad the guy is OK and nobody (including him) got hurt, but he deserves it for putting BBS center caps on replica wheels.. But still, that is massive damage even for a replica wheel...

Not totally related to the topic in discussion but I think, if you're going to use replica wheels, take them for what they are and use them as replica wheels.. Simple.. It's not cool at all to put VOLK, BBS, RAYS, or whatever other logo on replica wheels to try to make them pass as genuine...

Originally Posted by Liquid_G

that's what you get for faking the funk..

the biggest fail in this thread as stated above is someone trying to pass off knock off wheels as genuine BBSs.

That center cap was probably just trying to escape/commit suicide and this was the result.

[nuTinmuch]

Pretty lame on the center cap, but I wouldn't use this as evidence against the quality of the replicas.

[Liquid_G]

Originally Posted by nuTinmuch

Pretty lame on the center cap, but I wouldn't use this as evidence against the quality of the replicas.

Really? so its normal for wheels to self destruct hitting a pothole at 25mph?

[dan avoN7]

Originally Posted by Liquid_G

Really? so its normal for wheels to self destruct hitting a pothole at 25mph?

The speed at which the owner reported hitting the pothole is very questionable. I also own a M3 and find it very odd that he was in 4th gear traveling at 25mph, let alone up a HILL. It's just speculation at this point but that struck me as odd..

Also it's not likely that the wheel came apart due to the impact. The pothole likely cracked the wheel and after driving for a little while longer (until he noticed there was a problem) the center separated from the rest of the wheel. A similar comparison can be made with tires. If you have a hole in a sidewall, blow the bead of a tire, etc.. and continue to drive on that flat tire it will eventually split in two right at the sidewall.

Knowledge.. the more you know

[Liquid_G]

Originally Posted by dan avoN7

The speed at which the owner reported hitting the pothole is very questionable. I also own a M3 and find it very odd that he was in 4th gear traveling at 25mph, let alone up a HILL. It's just speculation at this point but that struck me as odd..

Also it's not likely that the wheel came apart due to the impact. The pothole likely cracked the wheel and after driving for a little while longer (until he noticed there was a problem) the center separated from the rest of the wheel. A similar comparison can be made with tires. If you have a hole in a sidewall, blow the bead of a tire, etc.. and continue to drive on that flat tire it will eventually split in two right at the sidewall.

Knowledge.. the more you know

What knowledge do you have? I see a wheel that failed ridiculously after hitting a pothole.. THAT is not normal, and doesn't happen with quality wheels.

but please, share more Knowledge with us.

[kenchan]

i can almost bet the BBS center caps were also fake!

[dan avoN7]

Originally Posted by Liquid_G

What knowledge do you have? I see a wheel that failed ridiculously after hitting a pothole.. THAT is not normal, and doesn't happen with quality wheels.

but please, share more Knowledge with us.

I've worked in the wheel industry for 5+ years. I've worked closely with various wheel manufactures over the years and have a lot of knowledge regarding manufacturing, R&D, sales/marketing of wheels, etc.. I have no ties to Varrstoen wheels but you can't judge a wheels quality based on one picture floating around the internet..

You, like many others, assume a wheel holding together in one piece after a given impact equates to it's quality. This is true but only to a certain extent.. If I posted pictures of Advan Wheels, Work Wheels, Enkei Wheels, etc.. with the spokes separated from the barrel would you say they are an inferior wheel?

[Liquid_G]

lol.. if they separated from hitting a pothole yes, but good luck with your search.

[kenchan]

for me, its not just one picture i am basing my judgement on. ive seen a handful with cheap wheels 'shattering' vs bending...

[phelan]

Originally Posted by dan avoN7

The speed at which the owner reported hitting the pothole is very questionable. I also own a M3 and find it very odd that he was in 4th gear traveling at 25mph, let alone up a HILL. It's just speculation at this point but that struck me as odd..

Also it's not likely that the wheel came apart due to the impact. The pothole likely cracked the wheel and after driving for a little while longer (until he noticed there was a problem) the center separated from the rest of the wheel. A similar comparison can be made with tires. If you have a hole in a sidewall, blow the bead of a tire, etc.. and continue to drive on that flat tire it will eventually split in two right at the sidewall.

Knowledge.. the more you know

Ah, that is possible. The pothole caused the initial crack on the lip, and as he kept driving, the crack continued to develop and displace to the center disk.

Would be interesting to do a stress analysis on it, but meh, too much work.