BMW M4 or Lexus RCF?

kenchan

yah, GTI's do look better in the 4door hatch for sure.

Magic Bus

DLSTR, you got rid of the Z for the M?

UNKNOWN_370

What's up with that RC-F steering wheel? Looks like it belongs on the S.S. Minnow.

So you guys really don't mind that road-feel disconnect of full on electronic steering? IMHO... Steering feedback is so HUGE in the driving experience. I really appreciate the fact that, Infiniti is the Only company that made full on electronic steering for the Non sport Q50. And the Sport Q50 still has the hydraulic unit. Steering & Suspension feedback rule my world. Though the Z is numb at 8degrees R/L TDC at low speed... There's plenty of feedback during performance maneuvers and at high speed.

It's the main reason why I'm so anxious for the next gen Z and GT-R. Nissan seems to understand that performance needs to be increased without deleting the senses of the vehicle in motion. GTR, thankfully brandishes a draully. All the new sports cars took a hit on numb to no steering feel for a smidge more accuracy.
The only car thus far truly benefitting performance-wise from a full-on electronic steering is the C7. Yet I notice all reviews don't touch the subject on the C7 at all, so my statement may be inaccurate. The truth will come out in reviews, the second or third model year like with the toyobaru twins.

I just know the mustang steering feel is the worst of any sports car and is an instant deal breaker. (elec-steer)

From the M235 to the Z, you guys don't find elec steer a dull drive experience?

__________________
Favorite Quote.
"I'm not gonna kill you... I'm just gonna Bash Your Face In" Jack Nicholson-"The Shining". 1980

BlackZeda

I drove a manual and automatic M4 this weekend. Compared to the Z, yes they are extremely dull cars in regard to their drive experience, but I am buying a "sports coupe" (i.e. a sedan) not another sports car.

UNKNOWN_370

I get what you're saying but the key word here is "sport". Anything with sporty intentions should feel "sporty" in the driving experience. Sporty, I can see a car being slow, but have perfect balance, great feedback but still provides you with two extra seats, good fuel economy and a usable trunk... That's sporty.
Driving around in a fast car with no kind of feedback or sportiness in the steering and/or suspension combined is pretty much a car.... That goes fast.... Is precise... But without the soul of a sports car. It's just a precise, fast passenger car.
Like electric sports cars. No exhaust sound. No soul period! It's like going to an music concert but you can't hear.

The band's playing. Music is good and loud. But you can't hear it = Electric car.

Just my opiniom though and a thank you for your answer and honest opinion.

__________________
Favorite Quote.
"I'm not gonna kill you... I'm just gonna Bash Your Face In" Jack Nicholson-"The Shining". 1980

jlo370z

we have 3000 miles on our M4 now, and there is nothing dull about driving this car. its amazingly fast , not quite as fast as my boosted Z, but its friggin quick. very minimal body roll and the brakes are ones i can only dream for on my Z (i hope to make that dream true soon) Fit and finish is great, the technology, apps are nice features. it rides nice at normal pace and gets decent gas mileage. my wife tends to drive around in M mode all the time, and that makes for a jerky first gear the way we have it set up. its a head turner, wife has literally been chased into department stores to be told how cool her car is, that has happen to a z owner "said no one ever". and thats happen multiple times.

that being said, if I had to choose today to drive my highly modded Z vs a new M4, I would pick my Z. if my Z was stock, there is no comparison the M4 is better in every fasciate.

__________________
❝The Jlo370Z Build❞
523HP | 455 ftb tq | 11.5 PSI | 93 Octane
2017 Porsche 991.2 C4!l

UNKNOWN_370

1. When the Z came out in 08. People thought it was an exotic.
2. You stressed FAST. I'm talking about the soul of a vehicle. FEEDBACK
3. We're not making a case against BMW, so no need to get defensive over opinions.
4. Congratulations to you and your wife on the M4.

__________________
Favorite Quote.
"I'm not gonna kill you... I'm just gonna Bash Your Face In" Jack Nicholson-"The Shining". 1980

jlo370z

its text so i can see why people think someone may be defensive. that being said, Im not being defensive just stating my opinion after having some aggressive miles with her. it handles, its quick, its Fast and it has fit and finish out the waazooo.. Its a fantastic drivers car. and I know what you mean about the steering, as a former owner of a E46 I know what connected steering is, but the M4 is not horrible in any since of the word in my opinion.


I even stated I prefer my Z in its current state so I dunno how you took i was being defensive, just because i referenced dull? Maybe i should have used more smilies Ill move a long. Have a good evening and happy motoring

__________________
❝The Jlo370Z Build❞
523HP | 455 ftb tq | 11.5 PSI | 93 Octane
2017 Porsche 991.2 C4!l

BlackZeda

Actually these are great comments as right now I am struggling to decide what to do with my Z in the near future. When I characterize the M4 as being dull I am saying that in relation to the feel of the Z, which to me feels like you are riding in a hovercraft after driving a sedan (sports coupe, M4 included).

Granted it was a test drive and I would probably get to love the M4 when the sales dude isn't sitting there right next to me.

The options I am looking at are:
1 - Keep the Z and get it tuned
2 - Keep the Z (and boost it) and get a supercharged 4Runner
3 - Keep the Z (and boost it) and get a BMW 335i/435i XDrive (and get it tuned)
4 - Sell the Z and get a BMW M4
5 - Sell the Z and get a Lexus RC F
6 - Sell the Z and get a Corvette Stringray
7 - Sell the Z and get a Camaro ZL1
8 - Sell the Z and get a Subaru WRX STI

UNKNOWN_370

Granted, I'm in a similar situation.

1. Keep the Z and go F.I.
2. Go for broke & SELL the Z and get a 2012 GT-R & go switzer.
3. Wait and see what the Z35 will bring & tune that and get a new Benz C300..
4. Go for broke and get a Porsche GT-3.
(Risky but considering)
5. Sell the Z and get a corvette Z-07. But GM is making me nervous AGAIN.

__________________
Favorite Quote.
"I'm not gonna kill you... I'm just gonna Bash Your Face In" Jack Nicholson-"The Shining". 1980

BlackZeda

The M4 is about the top end of what I want to spend, so that would eliminate a couple of your recommendations sad to say. At GT-3 does sound fun...

Is your M4 auto or manual? Are you happy with the option you chose? Full or extended leather (or cloth)?

critical

fuk bmws

__________________
Quaife w/ gears |Stillen Gen 3|SOLD FI Resonated Test Pipes |SOLD FI 18'' | 25row Stillen Race | Progress 35mm/25mm sways | Swifts/Koni|Volk G25's| Stoptech SS lines||SPL Front/Rear Arms|

Magic Bus

Found this interesting.

2015 Lexus RC F and BMW M4 basically tie on racetrack - Torque News

b15

If Lexus can find a way to shed 400lbs this car would be a winner. Weight aside, I love everything about this car