![]() |
Quote:
|
I also like the green. Hopefully there will be this and a new Z to cross-shop in a few years when I'm ready to change cars!
|
|
Quote:
say wat now:bowrofl: My last two cars have been auto and even I know thats a joke. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
A true DCT transmission does not have a torque converter. Nor a Park gear. It is more akin to a manual than an automatic, although there is a computer in between your shifting and the transmission. Think of it as a robotized manual transmission, not an automatic with manual override. As someone adeptly pointed out in another thread on this forum, you already have a pilot hydraluic system between your clutch pedal and the actual clutch in a modern manual. And the 370Z will blip the downshifts for you unless you tell it not to. The DCT is an improvement over both. I can report from my 4C forum that even the most fervent advocates of the 3-pedal layout forget about the difference in about 10 minutes. Those who continue to bellyache about it have simply never driven a true DCT. If anyone is among the latter category, go test drive a true DCT car in manual mode before you judge. In a slow, touring car, 3 pedals are perhaps still preferable. On a real sports car, times have moved on. Shifts are lightnening fast, and fully driver controlled. You can make them as early or late as you wish, you just cannot slip the clutch. Instead, there are usually different driving modes recognizing varying driving situations (such as comfort, snow, or track), which affect the speed of clutch engagement. However, the opportunity to heel and toe is lost. |
Quote:
|
[QUOTE=ZCanadian;3743593]Correct.
I can report from my 4C forum that even the most fervent advocates of the 3-pedal layout forget about the difference in about 10 minutes. Those who continue to bellyache about it have simply never driven a true DCT. If anyone is among the latter category, go test drive a true DCT car in manual mode before you judge. In a slow, touring car, 3 pedals are perhaps still preferable. On a real sports car, times have moved on. QUOTE] I couldn't disagree more. I am on my second GT-R (had an '09 since '08, which I traded in for a '15 in '14), and I would never want to have only a DCT. For me, there is no comparison to driving a manual. Most people who buy a car seem to convince themselves that what they have is better, so in my experience most folks on DCT car forums say they love DCTs. Sure, they are faster and easier to drive (and I obviously love my GT-R, which you might say is the car that made all the other performance cars switch to DCTs). But the skill and involvement of a true manual connects you to the car in ways that a DCT is designed to disconnect you from. A DCT just performs it's function more efficiently than most (all?) people can. I just think that if efficiency is the only goal, then soon we will all be in self driving computer pods. |
[QUOTE=gsx95;3743719]
Quote:
I have a manual and a DCT. Will take the DCT over 3 pedals every day of the week, unless I’m just out Sunday driving. The DCT is faster shifting, and way more consistent on the track to not unsettle the car when at the limit (not just my words). It is also easier on the clutch(es) in traffic. It is true that it is far easier to master a DCT (and I’ve far from mastered a manual), but the feedback I get from other drivers who also have cars with either, including track instructors, is that they feel as close a connection with the DCT car as they do with the third pedal, and are faster around any course. However, to each their own. As long as the choice is offered. Except that more and more it isn’t. |
[QUOTE=gsx95;3743719]
Quote:
I feel connected to my cars by driving them. It has very little to do with what system manages the power in the gearbox. The totality of the experience is the connection. Too much so called 'enthusiast' focus on this manual obsession. Almost they seem to miss the point of the rest of the car. |
[QUOTE=ZCanadian;3743758]
Quote:
I do agree that having a choice is most important, but I don't understand why a truly dedicated car enthusiast wants to develop fewer driving skills. |
Mostly everything written about the DCT can be applied eventually to autonomous driving vehicles. Although I do like technology and appreciate progress, I for one prefer shifting through the gears. There is something quite pure about it. Long live the manual transmission!!!
|
For me it comes down to what I like when it comes to motorsports. NASCAR is my favorite where a bad shift could destroy an engine, and those guys are masters of the clutch pedal. BUT, If I were to be given a choice between a stock car or a Formula 1 car to drive, I would go open-wheel because of the incredible speed. I do love my manual at the moment though...hopefully I can keep it for a while.
|
[QUOTE=gsx95;3743942]
Quote:
|
[QUOTE=DLSTR;3744080]
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:32 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2