370 on Top Gear

ThoriumHotdog

I bet the put up a time next week but fail to show the lap.

shadoquad

The "" emote does not strongly enough convey my concurrence to this statement.

fairladyZ34

i like that the photographic aspects are the same, i like the shots and stuff. the editing or what its technically called

__________________
From Z to G to BMW and back to a G! Nismo for life

toxik

you guys complain way too much.

I liked the show, because I'm sick of seeing shows about Hot Rods and muscle cars on Speed Channel. At least this show features cars I like, and it's not even that bad...

__________________
Project Pearl Necklace - PW 370z 05/01/2010 - 07/06/2011 (sold)

shadoquad

It's like when the U.S. started its version of "The Office". I cannot enjoy it, because the original British version was better and more intelligently written. Same thing here. It's an imitator. Coming fresh to it, it's not so bad.

crash1369

Admittedly i have been thinking that the whole time, everything they do (or have done so far at least, and have said they will be doing) is just a copy of the others and done poorly in comparison. Now if I didn't know that already then US version would seem better, although all the previously mentioned complaints still stand. A good host can make crapping in shoe box watchable, if not entertaining, while someone with no character or creativity can make even the most riveting topic an intolerable experience to suffer through.

__________________

toxik

Yeah, but what can you do. Not naming it Top Gear, would make it seem like a cheap American Rip-Off. But having TG brand in the title casts a big shadow.

Still, I've been enjoying the show. I can understand the negative points people bring up, but it's really not that bad of a show lol. I enjoyed the whole EP, even the drift challange....

__________________
Project Pearl Necklace - PW 370z 05/01/2010 - 07/06/2011 (sold)

shadoquad

Well, it is still very new, so maybe the hosts will develop a more cohesive chemistry over the first season or two, and maybe they'll strike out with some original bits. I'm willing to give it a chance.

spearfish25

Does anyone else think that they don't portray the 'feel' of the cars they are reviewing? Something is missing in the video footage that makes me not take anything away from their segment about the cars. I feel like it's just video clip after clip of cars wooshing by. They miss the clips of the engine revving up in neutral, the clip of the car peeling away...things they capture in UK TG. With the Astons, I felt like I was watching dust trails more often than the cars. I actually fast forwarded most of this past episode. Segments are boring me...something is missing.

__________________
2013 Cadillac V-Wagon, RIP Z

travisjb

I do agree... not sure if it is the video or the fact that they don't capture the car well in the way that they describe it... jeremy has a way of capturing the key points about a car in 5-6 statements, and what he says is connected to the video... when he talks about the transmission not working in the ISF, you can see it trying to shift and hear it beeping (by the way, this was wrong! they forgot to put it in manual shift mode )

Re hosts... the FLD host would have been good IMO


Hey, what do you guys think about a 'tuner' segment in the show? there's such a big aftermarket crowd in the U.S. - I'm thinking they should pick a car a week to showcase, maybe starting with our resident 1,000 hp build! lol

__________________
2009 370Z #104
*For Sale*

nurseryboy

Riiiiiight. This statement made me laugh. I'm not picking on you, but when I read that, I started thinking of all the things Jeremy has said over the years and had to chuckle. A few examples:

Haha. I actually laughed some while reading through them.. But, as you can see, Jeremy is often far from factual (and even accurate) with his statements. We love him dearly, but lest we forget he doesn't like the Z... because it used to be a Datsun.

I think the big difference between the two shows right now is that the UK guys have 15 seasons under their belts, and all the experience (and improved humor) that comes along with it (not to mention their experience outside of TG), whereas the US guys have a measly 2 episodes under their belts, and not a whole lot of driving experience aside from Tanner. Give them 15 seasons, though, and I guarantee you they'll be much better.

Like someone said before, though, it's entertainment! These aren't supposed to be factual, realistic shows. Not everyone in the US is a redneck (s09e03), who would do all that to a Toyota Hilux (s03e05 and s03e06), and geeze, they've done a few episodes with racing a car vs people down a mountain (s04e09, s05e08, s15e05). Heck, Jeremy takes a Jaguar down a ski slope in the season 4 one! How is that any more factual or realistic than taking an Evo down?

I love the UK one, don't get me wrong. I think it's much better than the US one at this point, but again, they have 8 years and like > 120 episodes up on the US guys. Give it some time, and enjoy watching guys do crazy stuff with cars we'll never be able to afford!

travisjb

lol, didn't say he was factual, said he has a way of "capturing the key points"... every car design has compromises and he finds them, and of course he does seem to hold strong to his bias against all things japan

appreciate the quotes! hilarious!

__________________
2009 370Z #104
*For Sale*

kevr6

Fifth Gear Rules!

__________________

ThoriumHotdog

Same. I skipped the entire "big stars little cars" nonsense. I couldn't seem to care even though I enjoy the UK version very much.

ThoriumHotdog

If only the US hosts could come up with that type of insanity.