Intelligent key port aka fobgina question

semtex · 03-11-2010, 12:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugoneus

The principle operation of the FOB inside the keyhole is the same as RFID tags. The keyhole powers the FOB if it has no battery.

But why do you need to power the fob at all? You don't need to power it to start the car. It's passive RFID, and you can start your car -- fob in pocket -- even with the battery completely removed. The only thing the fob needs power for is for the lock/unlock/horn buttons to work, and to be able to lock/unlock the doors by just pressing the button on the outside of the door. Well, you're not going to be using the buttons on the fob while it's in the fobgina for obvious reasons. And there's no reason to get out of the car while the fob is in the fobgina to hit the external door lock button. I just don't see the functional value of the fobgina. It's not like it recharges a dead battery or something.

Hugoneus · 03-11-2010, 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex

But why do you need to power the fob at all? You don't need to power it to start the car. It's passive RFID, and you can start your car -- fob in pocket -- even with the battery completely removed. The only thing the fob needs power for is for the lock/unlock/horn buttons to work, and to be able to lock/unlock the doors by just pressing the button on the outside of the door. Well, you're not going to be using the buttons on the fob while it's in the fobgina for obvious reasons. And there's no reason to get out of the car while the fob is in the fobgina to hit the external door lock button. I just don't see the functional value of the fobgina. It's not like it recharges a dead battery or something.

That is not exactly true. You wouldn't want a passive RFID for your car, they are much easier to duplicate.

In this FOB, the car and the FOB exchange a sequence of encryption messages. Furthermore, the FOB never sends the car the same message twice. A microprocessor changes the sent message every time (based on an encryption key). This is the most secure method.

semtex · 03-11-2010, 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugoneus

That is not exactly true. You wouldn't want a passive RFID for your car, they are much easier to duplicate.

In this FOB, the car and the FOB exchange a sequence of encryption messages. Furthermore, the FOB never sends the car the same message twice. A microprocessor changes the sent message every time (based on an encryption key). This is the most secure method.

Okay, whatever. You obviously know way more about RFID than I do. But you completely sidestepped the main point I was trying to make about the fobgina having no functional value in this car (other than being a hole to stick your fob into if you don't want to keep it in your pocket). You previously stated that the keyhole powers the fob if it has no battery. What I'm saying is that there's no value in doing that as far as I'm able to see. i.e., the functions of the fob that require power won't/can't be used while the fob is in the keyhole/fobgina anyway.

Hugoneus · 03-11-2010, 02:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex

Okay, whatever. You obviously know way more about RFID than I do. But you completely sidestepped the main point I was trying to make about the fobgina having no functional value in this car (other than being a hole to stick your fob into if you don't want to keep it in your pocket). You previously stated that the keyhole powers the fob if it has no battery. What I'm saying is that there's no value in doing that as far as I'm able to see. i.e., the functions of the fob that require power won't/can't be used while the fob is in the keyhole/fobgina anyway.

The FOB performs several functions:

1) It allows you to remotely lock/unlock doors and activate the emergency alarm.
2) Allows you to lock/unlock the doors and trunk if you are in the proximity of the car.
3) Allows you to start the car as long as the fob is inside the car.
4) Prevents other people from unlocking your door by pushing the buttons on the door handles.

Obviously the FOB is designed to be beneficial if it has batteries. If it runs out of battery they still provide you with some ways to turn your car on until you replace the battery. If the FOB has no battery, you cannot remotely lock/unlock your car. That is the same with any remote key-less entry system.

My apologize, but I fail to see what your point is. Are you saying that a device without batteries is (mostly) useless? Yes, I agree it is.

semtex · 03-11-2010, 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugoneus

The FOB performs several functions:

1) It allows you to remotely lock/unlock doors and activate the emergency alarm.
2) Allows you to lock/unlock the doors and trunk if you are in the proximity of the car.
3) Allows you to start the car as long as the fob is inside the car.
4) Prevents other people from unlocking your door by pushing the buttons on the door handles.

Obviously the FOB is designed to be beneficial if it has batteries. If it runs out of battery they still provide you with some ways to turn your car on until you replace the battery. If the FOB has no battery, you cannot remotely lock/unlock your car. That is the same with any remote key-less entry system.

My apologize, but I fail to see what your point is. Are you saying that a device without batteries is (mostly) useless? Yes, I agree it is.

No, I'm saying that the fobgina is useless, not the fob itself. As I previously mentioned, just to experiment, I have taken the battery out of my fob, left the fob in my pocket, gotten in my car and it still starts my car. So obviously the fob does not need power in order to start the car. So what's left that does require power? Well, you mentioned pretty much all of them above. But here's the rub. You can send power to a fob with a dead battery by sticking it into the fobgina, right? Well, you're not going to remotely lock/unlock the doors or activate the emergency alarm while the fob is stuck inside the fobgina. Or to put it another way, by sticking your fob into the key hole, it'll power up the buttons on your fob, but your access to those buttons will be obstructed by the very fact that you have inserted the fob into the key holder. So what's the point of even having a fobgina to stick it into? As I said, you don't need it to start the car up.

ChrisSlicks · 03-11-2010, 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex

No, I'm saying that the fobgina is useless, not the fob itself. As I previously mentioned, just to experiment, I have taken the battery out of my fob, left the fob in my pocket, gotten in my car and it still starts my car. So obviously the fob does not need power in order to start the car. So what's left that does require power? Well, you mentioned pretty much all of them above. But here's the rub. You can send power to a fob with a dead battery by sticking it into the fobgina, right? Well, you're not going to remotely lock/unlock the doors or activate the emergency alarm while the fob is stuck inside the fobgina. Or to put it another way, by sticking your fob into the key hole, it'll power up the buttons on your fob, but your access to those buttons will be obstructed by the very fact that you have inserted the fob into the key holder. So what's the point of even having a fobgina to stick it into? As I said, you don't need it to start the car up.

When you took the battery out did you discharge any residual current remaining inside? I.e. press the buttons until they didn't work anymore? That would help determine if it uses passive or active RFID.

semtex · 03-11-2010, 05:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrisSlicks

When you took the battery out did you discharge any residual current remaining inside? I.e. press the buttons until they didn't work anymore? That would help determine if it uses passive or active RFID.

No, I did not do that.

tvfreakazoid · 03-12-2010, 05:37 AM

So, confusing.

03-12-2010, 05:37 AM	#8 (permalink)
tvfreakazoid A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: kommie kali Posts: 1,238 Drives: 2015 Audi S5; 6spd. Rep Power: 10325	So, confusing. __________________ Mudders milk

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Intelligent key question..	Steven	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	75	06-08-2015 05:32 PM
Intellegent Key Port	moondoggy	Exterior & Interior	28	06-21-2009 12:38 PM
IPOD Port?	kannibul	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	1	06-14-2009 09:37 AM
Where's the USB port?	Phimosis	Audio & Video	10	06-13-2009 02:49 PM
What Happens When Your Intelligent Key Malfunctions ??	dlmartin81	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	41	02-06-2009 09:45 PM