370Z or Boxster?

MightyBobo · 01-12-2010, 10:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmyride

To me, a Boxster is a poorman's Porsche.

Aesthetically(spelling) , it's ugly.

I'd take Z over Boxster anytime. In fact, if i see a Boxster on the road, i would not respect it nor the driver.

I would take CaymanS over Z, however. But then, Cayman is no cheap car.

The Cayman barely costs more than the Boxster really...base MSRP on the Cayman is only about $4000 more than the base Boxster...and the Boxster Spyder is about the same price as the Cayman S.

You aren't one of those, "If its not a 911 or more expensive, its not a true Porsche" guys, are you? Because I have news for you on that whole "rear-engine layout" junk...

KillerBee370 · 01-12-2010, 10:26 PM

Having owned (wifes car) and driven a Boxster for a number of years, I can give a simple point by point opinion of each.

Boxster:
Pros--
- Great fair weather car (can't beat a convertible with the sun on your face).. however the 370z has this covered now as well.
- Surprisingly comfortable on longer trips
- Trunk space is a bit better than expected and for those really large items, you can always drop the top and use the passenger side to get that coatrack home

- Superb handling in stock form.
- Nice features, quality feel.

Cons--
- Quick but runs outta steam compared to lesser priced cars (370z)
- Chick car styling. Let's face it, this is a chick car. (The Cayman isn't much better as it's called the "Cockster")
- Expensive upkeep.
- For the price you pay, Porsche's ALWAYS need to come equiped with STANDARD things such as Xenon lights, multi-disc CD players, etc. They do not.
- Did I mention it's a chick car? The only thing a guy could drive that looks more pathetic is a VW Beetle.

370z:
Pros--
- Interior styling and quality is on par or better than that of the Boxster (well it is with my touring package anyway)
- More powaa!!
- I've seen women driving them and it's sexy but it's not a "chicks car" like the Boxster.
- Lower maintenence costs.
- Lot's more pro's...

Cons--
- Small trunk space. It was better in the Boxster.
- Same blind spots as a Boxster with it's top up.

Porsche is a strong company but if I ever get a Porsche again (and I plan to), it will be a GT2 or GT3. Between the Boxster (or even the "Cockster") and a 370z... There's really NO comparison. 370z all the way.

cab83_750 · 01-13-2010, 02:26 AM

Was it Jeremy who said that having a Boxster is like telling yourself...."my life did not go as planned!"

if you want a Porsche go for the 911.

. Or a cayman.

Old Chuck · 01-13-2010, 05:58 PM

and that theme is that the Boxster and the Cayman are two different vehicles. Folks, they are not. Saying the Boxster is a poor man's porsche and buy the Cayman mentality just makes me wonder what folks are smoking. Also, saying if its not a 911 or more expensive p car then it is not worth having is absurd. I have driven the Boxster S enough to know that it handles as well as anything costiing thousands more does not run out of gas as you push it. Don't compare a new Boxster S to an older Boxster in terms of speed. They are quicker then the Z.
All cars are built to a price point and you usually get what you pay for. That goes for the Boxster or the 370Z. I guess, in hindsight, I should not have entered this post as everyone has their opinion and those do not change easily. To the original poster, buy the one that puts the biggest grin on your face.

WICKED_GRIN · 01-13-2010, 06:53 PM

VW/Porsche should put the 3.8L 500hp twin turbo in the Boxster/Cayman and shake up the Super Car world. Cayman Turbo 4S. The 911 should have been killed a long time ago. Rear engine cars are really old school. Rear engine = Sh!tty design.

UNKNOWN_370 · 01-13-2010, 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cab83_750

Was it Jeremy who said that having a Boxster is like telling yourself...."my life did not go as planned!"

if you want a Porsche go for the 911.

. Or a cayman.

I'm sure the million dollar porsche carrera gt owners think 911 owners are a bunch of wannabe's 911 owners are probably saying 370 owners are wishin. 370 owners put down genesis coupe owners. And genny owners are putting down eclipse owners... in the end. Who gives a F*&K. Drive what you like. If u enjoy it? That's all that matters. Your neighbors garage or someones shallow opinions shouldn't even be a factor in your driving decision. Drive what you love.

gumpy · 01-13-2010, 07:24 PM

I'd have to go the 370z cause I play golf and the car is useless to me if i can't take it to the course on the weekend.

However, if i was rich enough for two cars it would be the cayman... heard it's sick...

WICKED_GRIN · 01-13-2010, 08:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UNKNOWN_370

I'm sure the million dollar porsche carrera gt owners think 911 owners are a bunch of wannabe's 911 owners are probably saying 370 owners are wishin. 370 owners put down genesis coupe owners. And genny owners are putting down eclipse owners... in the end. Who gives a F*&K. Drive what you like. If u enjoy it? That's all that matters. Your neighbors garage or someones shallow opinions shouldn't even be a factor in your driving decision. Drive what you love.

The problem is that some people don’t know what they like! All it takes for some buyers is a car commercial with hot music or a sexy car ad in a magazine with beautiful models. Some people look at the engineering and technology. When somebody asks for advice, it might aid the reinforcement needed to really enjoy the car. Shallow opinions are what some people are looking for!

elmz · 01-16-2010, 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WICKED_GRIN

Rear engine cars are really old school. Rear engine = Sh!tty design.

That is some statement...have you driven a Cayman? The engine placement makes a world for a difference. I love the the 370 and its front midship engine design, its a very balanced car. But the Cayman's mid engine setup is superior, drive one if you get a chance, its pretty amazing.

WICKED_GRIN · 01-16-2010, 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elmz

That is some statement...have you driven a Cayman? The engine placement makes a world for a difference. I love the the 370 and its front midship engine design, its a very balanced car. But the Cayman's mid engine setup is superior, drive one if you get a chance, its pretty amazing.

A "mid-engine” car has the engine in front of the rear axle but behind the passenger compartment = best design.
A “Rear engine” car = Sh!tty design.

Yes, I have driven them.

cab83_750 · 01-17-2010, 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WICKED_GRIN

A "mid-engine” car has the engine in front of the rear axle but behind the passenger compartment = best design.
A “Rear engine” car = Sh!tty design.

Yes, I have driven them.

You do not say if you owned one AND driven one. There is a big difference like night and day.

If you actually owned one for some time, then I rest my case and I apologize.

dad · 01-17-2010, 10:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Quick Nick

Which would you choose?

The muscle, power and value of the 370Z are appealing, but the build quality and neutral handling balance of the Boxster is also very appealing.

I know the battle between Nissan and Porsche is well documented, as is the ownership experience of the Boxster, but I would love to hear from anyone who has owned/driven both.

Comments?

Get the Porsche!

motoextreme · 01-17-2010, 10:41 PM

I owned a 2002 996TT (basically a 911TT). Absolutely loved it, feels small, super fast etc etc

BUT...I paid twice as much for that car then my Z (I bought it used). The mod parts are much more not to mention the maintenance! What's worse is the $ you will lose when you go to sell it regardless of what model you choose.

I'm sorry to admit it but Boxsters really do seem like more of a girls car. If you don't do the 911 then do a 370, its my favorite car thus far and it makes me smile every time I start her up, you won't regret it.

WICKED_GRIN · 01-17-2010, 11:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by motoextreme

I owned a 2002 996TT (basically a 911TT). Absolutely loved it, feels small, super fast etc etc

BUT...I paid twice as much for that car then my Z (I bought it used). The mod parts are much more not to mention the maintenance! What's worse is the $ you will lose when you go to sell it regardless of what model you choose.

I'm sorry to admit it but Boxsters really do seem like more of a girls car. If you don't do the 911 then do a 370, its my favorite car thus far and it makes me smile every time I start her up, you won't regret it.

If the Boxster/Cayman and the 911 had the same engine/HP and raced on a road course, the 911 would finish in second place (first loser).

MightyBobo · 01-17-2010, 11:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WICKED_GRIN

If the Boxster/Cayman and the 911 had the same engine/HP and raced on a road course, the 911 would finish in second place (first loser).

^^^^

The Boxster is only crippled because the 911 is Porsche's defacto standard as far as image goes.

The sad truth is the Boxster is an optimal setup...if only it had the same engine offerings as in the 911...

01-13-2010, 05:58 PM	#49 (permalink)
Old Chuck Base Member Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Florida & SC Posts: 86 Drives: 05 Tundra& 02 Subaru Rep Power: 16	I still hear the same old theme and that theme is that the Boxster and the Cayman are two different vehicles. Folks, they are not. Saying the Boxster is a poor man's porsche and buy the Cayman mentality just makes me wonder what folks are smoking. Also, saying if its not a 911 or more expensive p car then it is not worth having is absurd. I have driven the Boxster S enough to know that it handles as well as anything costiing thousands more does not run out of gas as you push it. Don't compare a new Boxster S to an older Boxster in terms of speed. They are quicker then the Z. All cars are built to a price point and you usually get what you pay for. That goes for the Boxster or the 370Z. I guess, in hindsight, I should not have entered this post as everyone has their opinion and those do not change easily. To the original poster, buy the one that puts the biggest grin on your face.

01-17-2010, 10:41 PM	#58 (permalink)
motoextreme Track Member Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Chino Hills, CA Posts: 971 Drives: Nismo NO MODS! Rep Power: 369	I owned a 2002 996TT (basically a 911TT). Absolutely loved it, feels small, super fast etc etc BUT...I paid twice as much for that car then my Z (I bought it used). The mod parts are much more not to mention the maintenance! What's worse is the $ you will lose when you go to sell it regardless of what model you choose. I'm sorry to admit it but Boxsters really do seem like more of a girls car. If you don't do the 911 then do a 370, its my favorite car thus far and it makes me smile every time I start her up, you won't regret it. __________________ Fast Intensions / NST / Mishimoto / Alpine / JDM / Volk / Brembo / Rotora / Seibon / Stillen / Password: JDM / KW / MR Works / RAW / Sun Auto / B&M / Amplified Motorsports

01-12-2010, 10:26 PM	#47 (permalink)
KillerBee370 A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: So Cal baby! Age: 51 Posts: 5,964 Drives: with passion Rep Power: 321	Having owned (wifes car) and driven a Boxster for a number of years, I can give a simple point by point opinion of each. Boxster: Pros-- - Great fair weather car (can't beat a convertible with the sun on your face).. however the 370z has this covered now as well. - Surprisingly comfortable on longer trips - Trunk space is a bit better than expected and for those really large items, you can always drop the top and use the passenger side to get that coatrack home - Superb handling in stock form. - Nice features, quality feel. Cons-- - Quick but runs outta steam compared to lesser priced cars (370z) - Chick car styling. Let's face it, this is a chick car. (The Cayman isn't much better as it's called the "Cockster") - Expensive upkeep. - For the price you pay, Porsche's ALWAYS need to come equiped with STANDARD things such as Xenon lights, multi-disc CD players, etc. They do not. - Did I mention it's a chick car? The only thing a guy could drive that looks more pathetic is a VW Beetle. 370z: Pros-- - Interior styling and quality is on par or better than that of the Boxster (well it is with my touring package anyway) - More powaa!! - I've seen women driving them and it's sexy but it's not a "chicks car" like the Boxster. - Lower maintenence costs. - Lot's more pro's... Cons-- - Small trunk space. It was better in the Boxster. - Same blind spots as a Boxster with it's top up. Porsche is a strong company but if I ever get a Porsche again (and I plan to), it will be a GT2 or GT3. Between the Boxster (or even the "Cockster") and a 370z... There's really NO comparison. 370z all the way.

01-13-2010, 02:26 AM	#48 (permalink)
cab83_750 Track Member Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: CA Posts: 887 Drives: 09 NISSAN 370Z Rep Power: 417	Was it Jeremy who said that having a Boxster is like telling yourself...."my life did not go as planned!" if you want a Porsche go for the 911. . Or a cayman.

01-13-2010, 06:53 PM	#50 (permalink)
WICKED_GRIN Enthusiast Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: New England Posts: 466 Drives: 370Z Roadster Black Rep Power: 16	VW/Porsche should put the 3.8L 500hp twin turbo in the Boxster/Cayman and shake up the Super Car world. Cayman Turbo 4S. The 911 should have been killed a long time ago. Rear engine cars are really old school. Rear engine = Sh!tty design.

01-13-2010, 07:24 PM	#52 (permalink)
gumpy Enthusiast Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Sydney Posts: 449 Drives: 09 370z white manual Rep Power: 16	I'd have to go the 370z cause I play golf and the car is useless to me if i can't take it to the course on the weekend. However, if i was rich enough for two cars it would be the cayman... heard it's sick...