Thanks for all the comments.

Trust me I was skeptical at first, especially given the price. But everything checked out with the paperwork, odometer (250) and inspection on the car. The only thing I found "wrong" was the rear mat was heavily creased from being folded up for nearly 2 years. The door sticker shows it was manufactured 7/10 so my guess is that the dealer already had 11's on the floor with this, and wound up getting stuck with it.

I didn't buy for gas mileage but as my daily driver to work I wanted to get a baseline. If it stays low where it is, no big deal. I'll wait until I'm up around 3k to make judgments on that though.