Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Forced Induction (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/)
-   -   GTM Stage 2 Supercharger Preliminary Testing Results (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/36551-gtm-stage-2-supercharger-preliminary-testing-results.html)

christian370z 08-22-2011 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XwChriswX (Post 1274779)
Is it possible to say the price increase now that prices are posted?

And does this mean that we'll have the full press release out soon? Or is that still in the works?

Still wanna see justification that these don't work with LTHs other than just comments.

They do work with LTHs, you just might see slightly less power as seen on some stage 1 SC kits when installed on a car with LTHs. However, there are no stage 2 SC 370Zs out there yet with LTHs so the additional flow from the larger compressor might mean there won't be the loss in power.

XwChriswX 08-22-2011 10:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by christian370z (Post 1275109)
They do work with LTHs, you just might see slightly less power as seen on some stage 1 SC kits when installed on a car with LTHs. However, there are no stage 2 SC 370Zs out there yet with LTHs so the additional flow from the larger compressor might mean there won't be the loss in power.

It has nothing to do with power loss, it's said that the headers + the larger compressor simply won't fit together. Yet there hasn't been anything to substantiate this. I'm not saying anyone isn't being truthful, just I'd like to see some sort of labor evidence, or pics, or something describing why with a little bit more explanation than just 'it doesn't fit.'

I fully expect to see that if it can be worked to make these fit to see even more power than with stock headers.

1slow370 08-23-2011 03:46 AM

^maybe if you used a smaller pulley to get your psi back but without tuning the cam timing or shoving more air in you'll struggle to make more power with headers. Our overlap is soo bad for FI that a restrictive exhaust is actually helping to keep the air and fuel in the chamber.

wstar 08-23-2011 07:36 AM

Does anyone have hard confirmation that our cars do in fact have significant overlap?

theDreamer 08-23-2011 09:23 AM

Less power? I made 400whp which is just a few below Sam and I was running in 100+ degree weather.
The LTH in the end showed no loss in PSI or power, which means if we see VVEL being useful I would say the LTH will be the best bargain for a SC setup like every other car ever manufacture running a SC. In the end, you want to lose PSI with the LTH and be able to hold the power level which is what happens when a system is fully tuned.

darron 08-23-2011 10:54 AM

So do we have a estimate on when VVEL is gonna be cracked for tuning to make this problem not a factor anymore?

theDreamer 08-23-2011 10:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by darron (Post 1275804)
So do we have a estimate on when VVEL is gonna be cracked for tuning to make this problem not a factor anymore?

Soon
In a more realistic answer, no one knows. It all comes down to software for tuning, hardware needed (do we need a stand alone ECU), etc.

frostyrock7c 08-23-2011 07:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XwChriswX (Post 1275124)
It has nothing to do with power loss, it's said that the headers + the larger compressor simply won't fit together. Yet there hasn't been anything to substantiate this. I'm not saying anyone isn't being truthful, just I'd like to see some sort of labor evidence, or pics, or something describing why with a little bit more explanation than just 'it doesn't fit.'

I fully expect to see that if it can be worked to make these fit to see even more power than with stock headers.

I think the size of the compressor and the location of the air filter are why Stage 2 isn't compatible with LTH. Check out the press release photos... the air filter mounts behind the compressor at the end of a short tube.

XwChriswX 08-23-2011 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frostyrock7c (Post 1276990)
I think the size of the compressor and the location of the air filter are why Stage 2 isn't compatible with LTH. Check out the press release photos... the air filter mounts behind the compressor at the end of a short tube.

I know that's been the comment, then how do you explain it working with the Stock headers when they have a heat shield around them, and if you look at the Stock headers next to the FI LTH's they have the same profile and pipe routing... So It just begs the question for some sort of explanation...

frostyrock7c 08-23-2011 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XwChriswX (Post 1276991)
I know that's been the comment, then how do you explain it working with the Stock headers when they have a heat shield around them, and if you look at the Stock headers next to the FI LTH's they have the same profile and pipe routing... So It just begs the question for some sort of explanation...

:confused:

I guess we will find out in a few weeks. I won't be going with LTH but I will post some installed photos if no one beats me to it.

XwChriswX 08-23-2011 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XwChriswX (Post 1276991)
I know that's been the comment, then how do you explain it working with the Stock headers when they have a heat shield around them, and if you look at the Stock headers next to the FI LTH's they have the same profile and pipe routing... So It just begs the question for some sort of explanation...

See here:

http://i371.photobucket.com/albums/o...ns/Forum_2.jpg

Looks pretty identical to me... :ugh2:

frostyrock7c 08-23-2011 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XwChriswX (Post 1277000)
See here:

http://i371.photobucket.com/albums/o...ns/Forum_2.jpg

Looks pretty identical to me... :ugh2:

Agreed... strange indeed.

fstrnldr 08-24-2011 10:25 AM

Still confused why someone would go through the time to make a long tube head but not make it equal length.

Anyway since when is it GTMs responsibility to test their products for compatibility against other non OE manufacturers offerings? Maybe they didn't feel like spending the money and time to see if a part that offers them no income from sales fits w/ their kit. Maybe there is something that can't be seen in those pictures. Or maybe it is a heat issue. The fact that the OE piece is two layer steel + a heat shield (keeping more radiated heat inside the pipe) vs the aftermarket piece which is single wall tubing with no coatings or heat shields could play a big factor.

wstar 08-24-2011 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fstrnldr (Post 1278198)
Still confused why someone would go through the time to make a long tube head but not make it equal length.

Anyway since when is it GTMs responsibility to test their products for compatibility against other non OE manufacturers offerings? Maybe they didn't feel like spending the money and time to see if a part that offers them no income from sales fits w/ their kit. Maybe there is something that can't be seen in those pictures. Or maybe it is a heat issue. The fact that the OE piece is two layer steel + a heat shield (keeping more radiated heat inside the pipe) vs the aftermarket piece which is single wall tubing with no coatings or heat shields could play a big factor.

The FI LTH come in a ceramic coating for heat shielding. I suspect the walls are thicker too, though it's been a long while since I've seen my stock manifolds. Neither GTM nor FI are responsible for cross-testing with each others' products, but I think it is reasonable to ask that FI know and disclose any effect the LTH would have on an SC setup in general, and for GTM to know and disclose any effect a cat-less or LTH exhaust flow is going to have on their SC kit and why.

Both seem to have done so, and they come to conflicting conclusions. I don't have enough personal data or expertise to weigh in any further than they have already.

Some independent parties (e.g. theDreamer) have combined them and think there's no real issue given a proper tune though. Given FI's recounting of Shumby's experience, I'm not sure I put a lot of weight in that story one way or the other, just too little hard data and not enough experimenting done.

For reference, the very bottom of the top post here has FI's conclusions: http://www.the370z.com/intake-exhaus...ders-here.html

ND370z 08-25-2011 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fstrnldr (Post 1278198)
Still confused why someone would go through the time to make a long tube head but not make it equal length.

Anyway since when is it GTMs responsibility to test their products for compatibility against other non OE manufacturers offerings? Maybe they didn't feel like spending the money and time to see if a part that offers them no income from sales fits w/ their kit. Maybe there is something that can't be seen in those pictures. Or maybe it is a heat issue. The fact that the OE piece is two layer steel + a heat shield (keeping more radiated heat inside the pipe) vs the aftermarket piece which is single wall tubing with no coatings or heat shields could play a big factor.

GTMs responsibility to test their products for compatibility against other non OE manufacturers offerings?

I think thats true. GTM should be concerned about there products.
I can care less about the LTH. Especially at that price point.


But i want to see the press release and any updated info. I heard sam is working on the Automatic SC install still?

branz1029 01-14-2014 01:21 PM

Very well written write up..... Thanks

1slow370 01-15-2014 09:40 PM

Its quite simple really in a naturally aspirated engine with stock exhaust, the valve overlap on the engine allows the exhaust volume moving out of the head to scavenge the cylinder better allowing a greater intake volume to be pulled into the cylinder, it is timed up so that the valve closes before the intake charge begins to leave the exhaust valve. When you put headers on an NA car you improve the scavenging of the exhaust improving the intake charge to the point that just a little intake volume goes into the exhaust before the valve closes but the cylinder is filled with more intake charge regardless so it makes more power. On a supercharged car the intake charge is pressurized so that once the exhaust has vented enough that the cylinder pressure is equal to the intake pressure intake charge begins to flood out the exhaust valve long before it is closed, with a restrictor like a factory cat, or running a smaller exhaust diameter(2-2.5") with test pipes you allow manifold pressure to rise right at the critical point where the intake charge would over pressure the cylinder and flood out the open exhaust valve so the manifold back pressure holds the charge in.

This has been true for long before the 370z even came out, every supercharger kit manufacturer will warn about headers causing a loss in boost pressure, the fact is with a supercharger and the locked in cam timing the Z will make more power per cfm pumped into the engine with a restrictive exhaust. headers plus cam timing the way it is the engine wastes a large percentage of intake charge, so the header manufacturer tells you to get a bigger blower so that even though 10% of the intake charge is flying out the exhaust you will get your power back by shoving more in. The supercharger manufacturer tells you to put a more restrictive exhaust on the car so you waste less and get more pressure and power for the amount you spin the charger. In the end the both do the same thing you just have to pick whether you want headers and a more wasteful setup or a smaller setup that's more efficient.

Now if you can change the valve timing, grab your self some headers and turn the overlap down and enjoy the best of both worlds. Like I said none of this is new it's neither companies fault it's just the way it is, thats why back in the 60's a thing called a blower cam was invented.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2