Roof Spoiler Opinions
 

Can I get some opinions on a couple of the following combinations. Yes I know wheel color and other things will contribute to some looking better than others, but just kind of want overall general opinions.

1. Gloss Black roof, gloss black roof spoiler
2. Gloss Black roof, factory matched roof spoiler
3. Factory painted roof, gloss black roof spoiler
4. Factory painted roof, factory matched roof spoiler

Some friends have said that black roof and spoiler will "shorten" the look of the car. Just not sure which of the four combinations to go with. Let me know what you guys think. Feel free to comment on the different options or just one of them if you have experience or have done one or the other.

It Might Depend...
 

...on the car's primary color. A black roof on a red car will have a different impact than the same roof on a silver car.

Why not take a photo of your car and photo-shop in the roof and spoiler colors you are considering?

I'm lost on photoshop that's why lol

Gloss black roof - no roof spoiler