Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Engine & Drivetrain (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/)
-   -   In comparison to HR 350z Dynos (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/81211-comparison-hr-350z-dynos.html)

bacalhau1669 10-28-2013 09:47 PM

I suppose more time may be needed to see it all infront of us. I was and am a memeber of my350z and I feel like there are a lot of 350z owners that really push their cars and drag race them. I dont feel the same about this forum. Not to say that there isnt, but on my 350z, there were a few guys who pushed and encouraged many to get gears, use nitrous, try different tire setups, push a single turbo to 10's etc etc.

I dont see much the same here. perhaps when 370z's come into the $10k-$15k and parts become cheaper, we will see more.

Chuck33079 10-28-2013 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bacalhau1669 (Post 2545147)
I suppose more time may be needed to see it all infront of us. I was and am a memeber of my350z and I feel like there are a lot of 350z owners that really push their cars and drag race them. I dont feel the same about this forum. Not to say that there isnt, but on my 350z, there were a few guys who pushed and encouraged many to get gears, use nitrous, try different tire setups, push a single turbo to 10's etc etc.

I dont see much the same here. perhaps when 370z's come into the $10k-$15k and parts become cheaper, we will see more.

A fair point. Also, there were probably more 350s sold in the first year of production than 370s have sold in their entire production run.

bacalhau1669 10-28-2013 10:00 PM

Not sure how we all feel about wikipedia and all but....

Year U.S. Sales
2002 13,253
2003 36,728
2004 30,690
2005 27,278
2006 24,635
2007 18,957
2008 10,337

Compared to
Calendar Year U.S. Sales
2009 13,118
2010 10,215
2011 7,328
2012 7,338

By these numbers, the sales of all 370zs combined through 2012 is only slightly higher then 2003 350z sales.

Chuck33079 10-28-2013 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bacalhau1669 (Post 2545167)
Not sure how we all feel about wikipedia and all but....

Year U.S. Sales
2002 13,253
2003 36,728
2004 30,690
2005 27,278
2006 24,635
2007 18,957
2008 10,337

Compared to
Calendar Year U.S. Sales
2009 13,118
2010 10,215
2011 7,328
2012 7,338

Ok, the second year of 350 production ;)

7AT_Z 10-28-2013 11:10 PM

Andre my 370z would WAX any 350 at the track haha. If you still spin drag radials at the track with a stock car then must be terrible at racing. I'm more than confident that if I lined up against you, then your going to have a baddddddd time. I had a 350z and they don't compare to a 370. My friend has an HR 350 and he still can't come close to touching my car. they are two totally different animals

andre12031948 10-29-2013 08:02 AM

AGAIN-last time cause going away today
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 7AT_Z (Post 2545225)
Andre my 370z would WAX any 350 at the track haha. If you still spin drag radials at the track with a stock car then must be terrible at racing. I'm more than confident that if I lined up against you, then your going to have a baddddddd time. I had a 350z and they don't compare to a 370. My friend has an HR 350 and he still can't come close to touching my car. they are two totally different animals

1) I said 5/6 times that 370 has more H.P & potentials.
2) We should ONLY talk about 07/08/ HR's because DE's had passenger car's engines TRUTH!!! & it's not honest to put them in the mix.

3) is for the above^^^^^poster. You didn't read my posts because if you had you would know that even with my car running STOCK intakes, STOCK Nissan exhaust, minus cats. you/your car would have to go UNDER 12.4's to beat that car!!!! My car was at & looked at 4 top car shops & always hood open at the track & was inspected by many. It was a VERY MILDLY MODED! + slicks....

2011 Nismo#91 10-29-2013 09:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by andre12031948 (Post 2545483)
2) We should ONLY talk about 07/08/ HR's because DE's had passenger car's engines TRUTH!!! & it's not honest to put them in the mix.

HR had a truck engine! Truth??? :wtf2:

1slow370 10-29-2013 11:40 AM

The HR has a truck engine that has gone full circle and is now passengr car engine!! Just like the vhr will!! Nissan recycles R+D truth

But yeah the DE sucked

andre12031948 10-29-2013 12:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2545801)
The HR has a truck engine that has gone full circle and is now passengr car engine!! Just like the vhr will!! Nissan recycles R+D truth

But yeah the DE sucked

That's what I meant.^^^^
Single intake, low flow headers, plain Jane cams/heads & a weak bottom end. Truck/car, it was a V-6 put into a sports car. It was a good idea then, but could not compete with newer combinations.

1slow370 10-29-2013 12:42 PM

Yeah and they did the same thing with the hr and the vhr.

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

1slow370 10-29-2013 12:43 PM

The jx and pathfinder are both hrs

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

andre12031948 10-29-2013 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2545942)
Yeah and they did the same thing with the hr and the vhr.

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

I kind of like the HR. Seen it inside. Very beefy rods. Super tough main bearing/crankshaft design, & the cams/heads are perfect for what it was build for. It's NOT an LS or Ford v-8 in H.P. but revs smooth with power in all rpm rangers & impossible to kill in N/A form. Love that engine for what it is/build for :)

1slow370 10-29-2013 01:06 PM

And the vhr is an improved version of the hr

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

andre12031948 10-29-2013 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2545965)
And the vhr is an improved version of the hr

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

What's with the vibration at higher rpm & the overheating. I didn't have that.

1slow370 10-29-2013 01:18 PM

I have never had an issue with high rpm vibration, dont know what that is but i can tell you the hr runs just as hot as the vhr you just dont have an oil temp guage in the 350

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

Chuck33079 10-29-2013 01:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by andre12031948 (Post 2545975)
What's with the vibration at higher rpm & the overheating. I didn't have that.

It came with the VVEL.

andre12031948 10-29-2013 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2545990)
I have never had an issue with high rpm vibration, dont know what that is but i can tell you the hr runs just as hot as the vhr you just dont have an oil temp guage in the 350

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

Could be. Now you tell me :)

1slow370 10-29-2013 01:26 PM

Because the 350 has no temp sensor there is no limp mode for high oil temps. So it "wasn't a problem" before

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

Megan370z 10-29-2013 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2546004)
Because the 350 has no temp sensor there is no limp mode for high oil temps. So it "wasn't a problem" before

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

From what I remember in my previous roadster HR. I installed an oil temp gauge and a medium sized oil cooler .... I never had big heat issue as I got with the VHR on bigger oil cooler setup
So yeah the vhr generate a ton more heat principlay from those VVEL heads

1slow370 10-30-2013 02:30 AM

The hr's had the water oil cooler installed from the factory too. And after adding it in '12 the vhr has much less issues with temps.

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

1slow370 10-30-2013 02:36 AM

The vvel systemdoes generate more heat, but in reality it isnt a whole lot more. Most of the heat that goes into the oil comes from the pistons, cylinder walls, and rotating assembly. There is very little that comes from the heads in comparison. Most of "the vhr runs hotter" comes from the missing factory cooler not the engine itself.

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

Joepro 10-30-2013 08:23 AM

first of all this thread is stupid. I owned at 03 350z, a de, and compared to the 370z that car was a like a daewoo in terms of fit finish and quality of materials....In terms of speed/times, without the same driver at the same track you will never get a true comparison. With that said, it is preference, but the 370 is a better car, it released with a declining economy and a msrp too high...it crippled the 370z...with that said, I have run the 1/4 mile in both my cars, and I admit I am a terible driver, but our track sucks too, everyone consitantly runs slower there, my buddy has an 11 second srt-4, by 11 I mean consisant 11.04-11.1 only runs 11.4-11.7 at our track...Before I sold my full bolt on 03 tuned by RT I ran a best time ofd 13.6... I took my 370z there this year and best time with bolt ons and no tune was 13.7, it was deplorable and my drving was horrid, I know that...so these results my 350z is faster than my 370(which is now tuned to 322whp, the de had 252whp) My DE would not touch a new 5.0 mustang, lets just say the 370 was raced at the "track" against a new 5.0 several times and my Z was victourious each run. Spatting off track times are usless is my point, get whichever car you like.

NickTurnon 10-30-2013 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joepro (Post 2546950)
My DE would not touch a new 5.0 mustang, lets just say the 370 was raced at the "track" against a new 5.0 several times and my Z was victourious each run. Spatting off track times are usless is my point, get whichever car you like.

You beat the new 5.0? The owner probably didn't know how to drive -

They consistently run around 12.6 don't they?

andre12031948 10-30-2013 10:06 AM

350 DE's
 
Should not even be in this thread!

I beat EVERY STOCK, only tuned Mustang at the track. The best one's in stock form did 12'6's. Which is way better than any tune stock Z. My car was tuned & mildly moded.

Joepro 10-30-2013 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NickTurnon (Post 2547152)
You beat the new 5.0? The owner probably didn't know how to drive -

They consistently run around 12.6 don't they?

Quote:

350 DE's

Should not even be in this thread!

ITS FOR COMPARISON PURPOSES OF FACTUAL DATA NOT ALL THIS HYPOTHEICAL BANTER.


Again, we did it multiple times to be sure, not saying I blew his doors off but it was stock. A friend of a friend has a 12 stang with intake exhuast and a flash, his best run was 12.6 at our track, consitent at 12.8. Before my headers and tune just to give your a mental picture that car would be Id say a little over a car length in front of me on a legitimate race -closed course simulated street racing from a 40 mph to 120 mph, at which point we were side by side until I hit 4th gear, the 370 falls flat...but it is much better in that area now that it is tuned. Next year when we go to the races I expect to be pretty even, I think from a legit 1/4 dead stop he will prevail, I expect to be around 13 flat if I learn to 1/4 mile drag.

My whole point is get the car you LIKE, if you LIKE the 350 get it, put money into it if you want it faster, end of story, but in direct comparision 370z>350z OVERALL.

andre12031948 10-30-2013 12:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joepro (Post 2547402)
ITS FOR COMPARISON PURPOSES OF FACTUAL DATA NOT ALL THIS HYPOTHEICAL BANTER.


Again, we did it multiple times to be sure, not saying I blew his doors off but it was stock. A friend of a friend has a 12 stang with intake exhuast and a flash, his best run was 12.6 at our track, consitent at 12.8. Before my headers and tune just to give your a mental picture that car would be Id say a little over a car length in front of me on a legitimate race -closed course simulated street racing from a 40 mph to 120 mph, at which point we were side by side until I hit 4th gear, the 370 falls flat...but it is much better in that area now that it is tuned. Next year when we go to the races I expect to be pretty even, I think from a legit 1/4 dead stop he will prevail, I expect to be around 13 flat if I learn to 1/4 mile drag.

My whole point is get the car you LIKE, if you LIKE the 350 get it, put money into it if you want it faster, end of story, but in direct comparision 370z>350z OVERALL.

For the tenth time,
The 370 has more H.P. & potentials than a 350hr does. Also 350 de cars should not be in the mix. I think I'm done here...:)

Megan370z 10-30-2013 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1slow370 (Post 2546790)
The hr's had the water oil cooler installed from the factory too. And after adding it in '12 the vhr has much less issues with temps.

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

I guess not every HR because my roadster didnt.
Im just comparing my previous HR with the VHR setup I had. My point is the hr ran cooler than my vhr.

Firebase99 11-11-2013 01:33 PM

[QUOTE=1slow370;2545801]The HR has a truck engine that has gone full circle and is now passengr car engine!! Just like the vhr will!! Nissan recycles R+D truth

But yeah the DE sucked[/QUOTE

I disagree. I thought the DE was so fun. It was sooooo punchy at low RPM, Im fairly certain my mostly stock DE was quicker than my 370 to 30mph. After that...forget about it.

1slow370 11-11-2013 03:20 PM

Yeah guess it really depends, you arent really doing anything under 30mph so in my opinion the de sucked. You arent even out of first gear under 30

Sent from my HTCONE using Tapatalk

Verda7junior 11-11-2013 04:15 PM

My 03 and 05 350Zs were alot of fun but at the drag strip the DE is too slow in NA form.
My stock 05 350Z 5AT 14.2@96
My stock 12 370Z 7AT 13.4@103

andre12031948 11-11-2013 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Verda7junior (Post 2564580)
My 03 and 05 350Zs were alot of fun but at the drag strip the DE is too slow in NA form.
My stock 05 350Z 5AT 14.2@96
My stock 12 370Z 7AT 13.4@103

I had a 2004 red 350z. The car was an all around fun little car. I liked it.
As far as the track, I wasn't & didn't even know moding. I didn't even know that there were forums.:)

The ONLY thing I did was put on Nitto nt555 street/drag tires(245/ ? /17's on my STOCK 17" wheels. I had a hard time getting traction even after heating them up, but managed a steady 13.7's like all the time. When I asked other DE Z owners with bolt ons, what times they did, most answered low 14's. I assumed my driving was better, now I think that sometimes the wrong or mismatched bolt ons can hurt the car's H/P/performance, and my driving WAS BETTER :p

To the relief of many here, I will NOT mention my HR :icon17:

Muney2bMade 03-25-2014 03:14 AM

Sorry to bring this thread from the grave, I posted this 6 days before I purchased my 350 HR. I'm not trying to dog on the 370's, but I have to say I haven't lost legitly to one thus far. Is my HR faster? Or are they terrible drivers? IDK, there's a billion factors.

So far I've ran 13.514 @ 106.22 with a 2.1 60'

The reason I prefer the HR 350 to the 370 is because, if, the 370 is faster, it isn't by a great deal, and that's not what the public would expect.


Example : Put a fender or half a car on an LS1 camaro, vs tie race between 350 hr and ls1 camaro. World goes crazy when 350 ties lol.

Chuck33079 03-25-2014 07:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Muney2bMade (Post 2752129)
Sorry to bring this thread from the grave, I posted this 6 days before I purchased my 350 HR. I'm not trying to dog on the 370's, but I have to say I haven't lost legitly to one thus far. Is my HR faster? Or are they terrible drivers? IDK, there's a billion factors.

So far I've ran 13.514 @ 106.22 with a 2.1 60'

The reason I prefer the HR 350 to the 370 is because, if, the 370 is faster, it isn't by a great deal, and that's not what the public would expect.


Example : Put a fender or half a car on an LS1 camaro, vs tie race between 350 hr and ls1 camaro. World goes crazy when 350 ties lol.

It's not just straight line speed, although the 370 does have more of it regardless of what you've seen. It's lighter. Shorter. Wider track. Stiffer chassis. Better brakes. And yes, it is faster. A 13.5 gets smoked by bone stock autos here all day. I'm glad you're happy with your purchase, but when the only person who agrees with you in your thread was Andre1234567, you're on the wrong side of a discussion. :rofl2:

Elan 03-25-2014 08:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck33079 (Post 2752172)
It's not just straight line speed, although the 370 does have more of it regardless of what you've seen. It's lighter. Shorter. Wider track. Stiffer chassis. Better brakes. And yes, it is faster. A 13.5 gets smoked by bone stock autos here all day. I'm glad you're happy with your purchase, but when the only person who agrees with you in your thread was Andre1234567, you're on the wrong side of a discussion. :rofl2:

That and it all comes down to the driver. The 370 is better in every single way. There is just no arguing against those facts.

litt1213 09-21-2014 06:28 PM

I have both the 370z sport touring and 350z HR and I ran 13.2 the first time I went to Atco and with berks hfc and stillen catback only pulled 13.4 in my 350 but it's not all about drag times the 370z is stiffer on the track that was the biggest difference on the track the car is a beast it's tight unlike the 350 it's everywhere way to much body role plus the 370 looks beautiful while the 350 is ehh needs alot of work to look nice. I can get into modifications and what's changed to help the car get that little extra power but it's unnecessary having both cars u can feel the difference just getting in the cars.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2