View Single Post
Old 01-14-2011, 02:32 AM   #93 (permalink)
Staples
Track Member
 
Staples's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Baltimore, MD
Posts: 546
Drives: '08 Infiniti G37s
Rep Power: 16
Staples is on a distinguished road
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by 1slow370 View Post
Well i have a few questions about that one as well if 500whp daily is the current safe build mark then i don't see superchargers going much further because you take the 430 available from a stage one kit and tack on the 50-70hp lost in driving said supercharger and the motor itself is actually seeing the load of a 480-500hp turbo motor less about 10-20% for the increased pumping losses and the heat wear on the exhaust side of the head. from what i've witnessed generally you can't push the internals to get the same whp from a supercharger that could from a turbo charger. And it isn't all about torque i would say it is all about cylinder pressures when you're talking about an 11:1 CP ratio. combustion heat and pressure, causing detonation are going to kill it long before the regular torque output of the setup will (not true with the de motors as they had bitch-rods). usually when judging between the two i like to go off system psi and air charge temp, so if the "safe" power level of TT setup is at 8 psi, and the air charge temps remain the same(intercooler and compressor efficiencies obviously), then i wouldn't try to push a supercharger setup much more than 10-20% over that so like 9-10 without more than one guy doing it first. now on the hr motors being able to run more psi safely with tuned valve timing to reduce the overlap, the same levels of power there should carry over between the engines do to the similarity of the build, less the increase in pressures for the half point of compression. Really there are quite a few unknowns on pushing a vhr supercharged as of yet. on another angle though the stage 2 could be worth the price if there is enough of a ceiling above the stage 1 blower and the kit price is close between the two. if an hr can run 14psi safely then it is a good bet that we should be able to get close to 12 with our compression maybe more because our heads have a smaller hotspot around the spark plug. then it is just a matter of making that 50-80 hp cost effective to the consumer in the upgrade price. on the same token the vvel controller would have to cost at least as much as the stage 2 upgrade or people will just buy the vvel controller and see the same gains for less jeopardizing stage 2 sales

It might be better to sell the -91 compressor as a stage 3 upgrade once the vvel controller is completed in that case, and sell the stage one plus vvel as the stage2.
Although a lot of what you're saying is true, nothing can be justified until the VVEL is cracked and the cost of the controller is listed. I have a feeling the controller is going to be a lot more expensive then what people think. I still say the extra $500 can still justify the cost of the stage 2 for a pure plug and play kit.

Of course my 2 cents
__________________
'08 Infiniti G37s - Forced Induction Fed
Staples is offline   Reply With Quote