Thanks for the pointer SoCal. I was gonna hold out and actually read the manual for the garage door opener. After reading this thread last night when I pulled out of the garage this morning I grabed a stool and looked at the garage door opener - haha its a Liftmaster and it says on the back press the learn button then press the new remote transmit button within 30 seconds. I had already programmed the controller into the Homelink but hadn't done the learn yet. Pressed the learn button and ran back to the car pushed the transmit then the light flashed in the garage and I was good to go. Took less time than it did to type this post