Originally Posted by Cmike2780

Get the most car you can afford... otherwise you will regret not having those options in the first place. The Touring with sport package is well worth the price tag and you do get a lot for the money. The upgraded wheels, brakes and LSD alone covers more than the $3k premium for the S/P. The touring interior adds a lot of comfort options that makes the everyday commute that much more enjoyable. It really depends a lot on what you want to modify later, like wheels, lsd, seats etc....

The Cayman is too much when you consider maintenance cost in my opinion and your stuck with an older car like you said.