I'm sorry bro. You probably know about the guy in Hicksville who had this experience too:
370z sport wheels stolen!!! Help!
You say you are in Nassau too - it has to be the same people who did this.
Can you link me to the guy from Suffolk who had this issue too, I'm in suffolk as well, I have base wheels though not sports, and we have two sports car in the driveway with a camera system me and my buddy with the other car bought half and half together.