It's your call. I don't think I'd trade my Z in for a base camaro SS but for a C6 (Z51), yes I would. I live two blocks from WORLD'S Largest Corvette dealer. At any given time, there are at least 50-100 corvettes on the lot. I drive by them 8 times a day. I must say, Z06s are very tempting.
I drove F-body Camaros for a long time. It's all fun when new, then things start rattling, parts start going bad etc. Heck, I was afraid to push my Camaro because every time I did, I broke something
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/85e52/85e5252d294808e8ecabec101ea3c2917919150e" alt="Frown"
. Something went wrong or a rattle started etc. This is just my
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/37da9/37da9a95cb4aef6afffaf564930ccbfbfea9f78e" alt="Two Cents"
. Go for a 'vette