Originally Posted by djburke87

What I would do is remove the map light assembly and check the push button switch that turns the light on and off. Or you could try poking it a few times to see if it is just stuck or something. Sometimes the bulb is just stuck in there weird, and you have to wiggle it to get it to light, but since you have tried several bulbs I doubt that is the problem.

The reason I think it is the push button switch (not the on/door/off switch) is because the same controls control both lights according to the Factory Service Manual (FSM). If it is not the push button switch, it might be the bulb socket.