Originally Posted by JARblue

I wasn't searching. I started the process online to file a dispute. Once you begin the process, the website will give you a list of transactions that are eligible to dispute - there are no search parameters involved on my end. My dispute list only goes back 90 days. When I spoke to PayPal about this, they said if the transaction does not appear in the list to dispute, then it cannot be disputed.

YMMV apparently...