New numbers. Apparently our cars don't hold an alignment well (crappy roads?). Top numbers are as I drove in, bottom numbers are as they now sit. My toe was definitely out and it's on the side with more wear. They did a realignment for free which was very nice of them and they even walked me back to show me a few things. It also helps that they're a mile from my house. I should be able to make it long enough for the new wheels/tires to come in.