Originally Posted by Z&I

If you do a Google search you will find that there are a few of them:
Ethanol stations near NYC:
I've been checking some of them out.
The one in Spring Valley is pretty good - all the street racers go there.
The [Power Gas] one in East Orange charges $4.99 a gallon...
There are others. I did this search based on my home location in Northern NJ

[Excluding private stations]
A.
BP
594 Nepperhan Ave
Yonkers, NY 10703
Phone: 914-294-0469
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 7.8 mi

B.
Sunergy
690 Main St
New Rochelle, NY 10801
Phone: 914-632-8617
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 12 mi

C.
Shell
1 N Broadway
Irvington, NY 10533
Phone: 914-591-6766
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 13 mi

D.
Power Gas
205 Sanford St
East Orange, NJ 07018
Phone: 973-678-2002
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 15 mi

E.
Sunoco - ZSA Petroleum
298 N Main St
Spring Valley, NY 10977
Phone: 845-371-6989
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 16 mi

F.
Newark Liberty International Airport
100 Linberg Rd
Newark, NJ 07114
Phone: 973-624-0300 516-710-1898
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 17 mi

G.
Banahan Brothers
310 Theodore Fremd Ave
Rye, NY 10580
Phone: 914-967-9619
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 18 mi

H.
BP
102 Lake Rd
Congers, NY 10920
Phone: 845-268-6454
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 18 mi

I.
Norman's Auto Service
77-40 Hewlett St
New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: 718-347-3400
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 19 mi

J.
JFK Airport Travel Plaza - National Grid - Clean Energy
150th Ave and 147th St
Jamaica, NY 11430
Phone: 718-553-0501 866-809-4869
Fuel: Ethanol (E85)
Distance: 20 mi