My office is within walking distance of an ABC store, so I picked this up last week. I've never had any of them before, and I'm pleased to say that I enjoy them all.
The Tullamore Special Reserve is incredibly smooth. Probably the smoothest 12-year I've had yet.
Whistlepig Rye is fantastic... if you like rye.
Michter's is pretty damn good. A little smokey and very sweet. Probably one of the cheaper "premium" bourbons around.
Ardbeg Corryvreckan... it's an experience to say the least. If you like smoke, peat, and complexity I think you'll like it.