I couldn't wait until tomorrow morning to use the multimeter, so I went into the garage and pulled it out. Turns out that one of the fuses labeled "Meter" in the fuse box located next to the driver's feet was blown, but not visibly separated! Replaced the fuse and everything works now! For those who might run into the same problem, I have attached a few pics to show the location of the fuse box, along with the 2 locations of the fuses that are labeled "Meter."
Thanks a bunch for the help guys! I really appreciate it
http://i1011.photobucket.com/albums/...psbjzyitkb.jpg