Couple of suggestions...
There has to be a paint code out there for the interior trim. There are a couple of spray paint manufacturers that work off these codes and sell cans direct to the public. Get an can of the silver and a can of satin clear pull the shift housing off sand down that chip rinse with h20 and pressure air dry. Spray a super light dusting coat of the silver in a ventilated area free of dust and particles in the air wait 15 minutes then repeat... Then repeat again.... Then repeat again... Then if you're not to high on fumes go ahead and spray a light coat of clear then repeat a couple more times.
Or do what cooltoy said and buy an awesome cf bezel for the shifter!!!