Hey guys, I know this is kind of an old post bump but I thought i'd make a final update. I ended up taking the check as insurance policy wouldnt give me back the 500 deduct. Check was 760.00. My cousin unscrewed reached in and pushed out the damage with his hand and we are just leaving it at that. Heres before and after Pic. Thanks for everyones help.
BEFORE:
Imgur
AFTER:
Imgur