Originally Posted by moore.speed

On your 10.5" wheel, you will be fine with a 255/35 but I'd advise taking your front tires and moving them to the rear for the 265 on the 10.5" wheel, if you must go this route. As for the 9.5, I wouldn't want to go any smaller than 235/35 but that is just a mild stretch, as you were looking for.