Let me lend you my advice... Take them off, take them to your local shop. Be nice to the people running the place and they will probably work out a deal with you. Paid $65 to have mine done....... I drove with no door handles for a week, just put blue painters tape over the holes...
I promise you wont be dissappointed...
Dont plasti dip them, you have a $25k car, plasti dip does automaticlly solve every problem.
My car -------->
|