Are you selling the Golf R? I hope you're not because I really like that car! I know what you mean about being fixated on the 'new or used' aspect of it.
My first car was a VERY used Mercedes S500 that my dad bought from a police auction at too good of a price. It was dropped and had 21" chrome wheels on it, and the tacky light colored wood trim on the inside (keep in mind I have always been a nerdy guy ever since high school, so this type of drug dealers car was very odd for me to say the least! Not saying that 21" chrome rims are for drug dealers, but trust me if you saw this car in its entirety). It was the only automatic car I've driven that actually stalled (on a regular basis).. Ever since then and after all those bad experiences with maintenance on the car, I have been buying nothing but new cars, and the peace of mind that you're talking about is very important.
So go with the Z!
__________________
| EVO X MR | '11 WRX STI | 370Z SPRT | 911 (991) C2S |
|