If it were my decision, I would compare #1 or #2. Both the Acura and Subaru should be very reliable based on previous model history. I do not have any experience with the Range Rover.
The Acura will probably have a nicer interior than the Subaru, probably pretty close to that of the Range Rover.
If I were in your shoes, I would go and look at them and go with whichever one you like best, and which one fits your budget the best.
Parts for the Forester will probably be the cheapest since it shares a lot with the Impreza.
Performance-wise, I think the turbo Forester is just as fast as the Acura. As long as you don't drive like an idiot and think you are invincible in the snow, they should all be able to handle the winter weather.
|