View Single Post
Old 02-14-2012, 11:29 PM   #125 (permalink)
Speedy
Enthusiast Member
 
Speedy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: TN
Posts: 390
Drives: check my signature
Rep Power: 13
Speedy will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by sfearl1 View Post
i believe my car had a noticeable improvement in throttle response after adding the drop in filters.
This is simple enough to test. I can just pull the filters out of my air boxes. If you had a noticeable improvement with drop ins, then I should REALLY notice something with no filter at all. I'll check it out this weekend and report back.

Quote:
Originally Posted by PaulZ370 View Post
Try this at home with your vacuum cleaner:

Turn it on, then use the attachments on the hose. You will notice that the more restrictive the attachment, the more "whine" the motor makes as it strains to pull the air through the attachment's opening. The more the motor strains, the more HP is being used to Pull the air into the attachment. In the case of a car, this means there is less HP to drive your wheels.

Same principle applies on the intakes and exhausts of cars as I've noted above.

Give the engine a larger "attachment", and it doesn't have to work as hard on "sucking" the air into the chambers. Free-er air flow = less work the engine has to do just to breathe, the more HP is now left over for the drivetrain.

Why do I know this? I am an engineer - and as such, I have dealt with calculating useable HP for Generator Engines considering pressure drops due to intake and exhaust piping. Piping (both intake and exhaust) have a tremendous effect on useable HP from the engine. This was a major factor in my choosing the FI exhaust system by the way - it has the least bends with the least angles (no 90's) which I know for a fact translates to less back pressure and more useable HP at the engine as a result. Intakes work the same way. The less bends and less pipes, the easier the engine breathes, the more useable HP is available for the drivetrain...

This is not hearsay, nor conjecture, nor abstract theory. This is something I have done as a matter of practical engineering - I make my living this way by the way, with 22 years experience in the industry, if that means anything to anyone out there...
I'm also an engineer and have been messing with cars since I was old enough to hold a wrench. Comparing a 332HP motor to a vacuum cleaner...meehhhhhhh.

The question becomes if the intake restriction creates vacuum at the area just behind the throttle body when at WOT. If so, then a larger air filter is warranted, if not....well not so much.
Speedy is offline