I prefer satin but definitely gloss black on the roof. It flows way better with the front and rear windshield. Even worse I've seen a matte black roof on a local MB Z and it looked terrible. Mine is a gloss black vinyl. Take a look at my photos in the member Z gallery (Dallaz 370). And I would do the burgers in satin too. It looks good and the spot feels empty without them there, but then there's the silver fairlady emblem.... Shoot!