I had damaged my cubby lid with a GPS mount and after trying for many months to buy a used one, I gave up. I didn't want to spend $125 on a new one either.
I bought some Hexxis 3D Carbon Fiber film (vinyl similar to 3M Di-Noc) and went at it.
The first picture is of the damage. I decided to do the door switch plates also.
The film is very deep and looks very close to real CF IMO.
Another pictures to show how good this film looks.